Catcher in the Rye Argumentative Essay
!.?.!? Argumentative Essay: Catcher in the Rye Holden Caulfield has been referred to as smart but cynical. As much as others attempt to persuade me or else, he is crazy. Holden reveals viewers evident indicators of trauma, he is contradictory concerning nearly anything and among the greatest and most apparent signs is that this story is told by Holden from a psychological institution. Holden reveals visitors many visible sings of PSTD (post-traumatic stress disorder).
There have actually been two occasions in his life which might have triggered this disorder. He has actually had to deal with Allie’s fatality because of leukemia and also James Castle devoting self-destruction while using the sweatshirt Holden had actually lent him. Among the largest signs that somebody has PSTD is when they are regularly reliving the terrible events over and over again in their heads. Holden regularly refers to seeing the face of his dead schoolmate James Castle but he doesn’t seem to have any type of emotional reaction to any one of it.
Holden also seems to chat still talk to Allie, out loud, despite the fact that he has passed away. PSTD can likewise trigger thoughts of self-destruction as well as we discover that in the book when Holden states that he seemed like committing self-destruction by simply jumping out the window. “What I actually seemed like, though, was committing self-destruction. I seemed like jumping gone. I most likely would’ve done it, also, if I ‘d made sure someone would certainly cover me up as quickly as I landed. I didn’t want a lot of dumb rubbernecks looking at me when I was all gory” (Salinger, Ch. 4). All these signs can quickly come from anxiety and/or confusion in his life. J. D. Salinger likewise experienced PSTD after returning from The second world war. So while I still think Holden Caulfield is insane, J. D. Salinger need to be just as crazy. The truth that Holden opposes himself a lot verifies that he is in reality, insane. He claims that he despises all these individuals like Ackley, Sally, Stradlater etc. Holden states he discovers them all frustrating and often contemporary best silly.
So then why does he act nice to them? Why does Holden claim to like these people whom he hates a lot? Holden also points out that he is an atheist however he constantly discusses Allie in heaven: “”Allie’s dead– You always state that! If somebody’s dead as well as whatever, and in Heaven, then it isn’t really–” (Salinger). Something else Holden does is he mentions all the freaks that he translucents his hotel window and also just how odd they are but at the same time he is waiting for a woman of the street.
There are a ton of various other instances however the point is that Holden is a really contradictory person. Overall, Holden is probably the most inconsistent individual I understand. That’s quite ironic though because that makes Holden the most significant phony I understand also. As well as Holden despises phonies. So in the end, does he dislike himself? The last as well as most evident disagreement that I believe no one can really argue is that the entire publication is told from Holden’s perspective while he is in a psychological establishment.
Holden had a worried breakdown due to all the anxiety he’s been managing. Nevertheless I do not believe he’s the only individual with issues like these. There has to be something incorrect with him for him to end up in an asylum. And also if he can not deal with his problems by himself, I think he belongs in an establishment. These are just several of the reasons why Holden Caulfield is insane. He is an inconsistent, cynical, insane 17 years of age with problems anybody else can have as well as if he can’t deal with them, he requires aid.