StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Are Liberty and Security Mutually Exclusive, or Mutually Supportive - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Your Name Prof’s Name Date Are Liberty and Security Mutually Exclusive, or Mutually Supportive? Liberty is supposed to be one of the foundational principles of any democracy – people should be free from fear, free from threat, and free to pursue their own interests, within certain bounds…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
Are Liberty and Security Mutually Exclusive, or Mutually Supportive
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Are Liberty and Security Mutually Exclusive, or Mutually Supportive"

Download file to see previous pages

A careful analysis of theory and practice of security, however, indicates that security is not opposed to liberty, and in fact augments it when used judiciously, but that there is a fine tipping point after which security begins to impinge on liberty rather than support it. The question as to the role and purpose of the government has been a central question to political philosophers for centuries now. These philosophers often work under to distinct precepts that were originally envisioned by Francis Bacon, Thomas Hobbes and John Locke: that people were born free in their “state of nature” (Hobbes 32), but that they are universally found to be under some sort of governance, which curtails their freedom.

The fundamental question is then, why do people give up their freedoms to another power? An explanation, the social contract, was developed by John Locke – he states that absolute liberty is not in fact a good thing, because it would mean liberty to steal from, and otherwise harm one another, so people give up their own liberty for security (Dunn 75). . e of the legitimate rolls of government was the regulation of morality: it was supposed that this was a form of security, and that without a patrician government to look after its population people would devolve into immoral behavior, and thus would harm themselves and the state.

John Stuart Mill countered this thinking in his seminal On Liberty, in which he argued that it was not a legitimate role of government to regulate morality (Mill 374). This shifted thinking permanently on the role of government in the preservation of liberty. Both of these trains of thought are in fact correct. It cannot be denied that government’s granting and increasing security does, to a particular point, improve liberty: a well policed street will ensure that people have the ability to walk down it unmolested, and a well regulated market ensures the liberty of everyone playing by the same economic rules.

Yet it also cannot be denied that governments sometimes go too far in curtailing liberty at the cost of security, by, for instance, monitoring people without their knowledge, or policing ideology (Rovine 42). So where does the tipping point occur? Government’s enacting of security begins to unduly curtail liberty when actions taken in the name of security modify people’s behavior more than the threat or fear of a lack of security would do. For instance, locking everyone in a solitary cell would certainly lower the murder rate, but this would modify people’s behavior much more than the fear of murder does.

A well regulated police force, on the other hand, increases liberty by countering the behavior modification that fear of murder by a completely un-policed society would have. Security and liberty are often seen as each other’s antithesis, and for good reason. Governments have

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Are Liberty and Security Mutually Exclusive, or Mutually Supportive Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1453875-security-and-liberty
(Are Liberty and Security Mutually Exclusive, or Mutually Supportive Essay)
https://studentshare.org/english/1453875-security-and-liberty.
“Are Liberty and Security Mutually Exclusive, or Mutually Supportive Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1453875-security-and-liberty.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Are Liberty and Security Mutually Exclusive, or Mutually Supportive

Positives and Negatives of War Bonds During World War 2

hellip; A war bond, simply put, is a special type of security.... War bonds What are war bonds?... War bonds are debt securities which are issued by a government during times of war mainly for the purpose of financing military operations.... There are several distinct advantages of war bonds poses but to gain a firm grasp to establish an understanding of these an analysis of what a war bond typically means has to be done....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Social Policy and Welfare Regimes

A very popular view among economists is that ‘globalization exacerbates human insecurity in both rich and poor countries.... This has had both negative and positive implications for social policy in different welfare regimes and will continue to do so if things are not brought… Globalisation has been defined in many ways Bordo et al (2003, qtd....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Roles and Responsibilities of Government Towards the Public Health of Citizens

This paper talks about public health, ideally, refers to a collective responsibility by people that seeks to promote and protect the health of a particular population.... In many instances the government plays the leading role in the collective interventions that seek to ensure population health....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Public Administration and Analytical Observations on the Works of Theodore Lowi, Hayeks Legal Theory

From the paper "Public Administration and Analytical Observations on the Works of Theodore Lowi, Hayek's Legal Theory " it is clear that Lowi has been right that populist conservatism is a threat to liberal rights as it only recognizes the authority of God, scripture, tradition and community norms....
33 Pages (8250 words) Research Paper

NSA's Phone and Internet Surveillance

"NSA Phone and Internet Surveillance: An Issue Attempting to Balance Security, Liberty, and Human Rights" paper examines the conceptions of liberty and established laws that support phone and Internet surveillance to determine whether such legislation violates the supposedly inalienable guarantee.... nbsp;… Not only is society potentially impacted in terms of liberty protections and human rights protections, but even the companies that sustain these communications channels by being forced to succumb to sovereign forces in government to cooperate with questionable and debatable moral and ethical activities in the pursuit of enhancing national security....
20 Pages (5000 words) Coursework

Immigration Policy and Immigration of the Wealthy People

This term paper "Immigration Policy and Immigration of the Wealthy People" focuses on the problem that arises when the supposed immigrant is a wealthy person and the question of sovereignty comes forth in the determination of the immigration policy to be applied.... hellip; Each state in the international system of nations enjoys unrivaled sovereignty over the affairs of its territories....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Managing Security Aspects of Immigration in a Post 9/11 Environment

The report "Managing security Aspects of Immigration in a Post 9/11 Environment" focuses on the critical analysis of the effects of immigration to the US after the post 9/11 environment on security aspects of the country.... Although immigration is vital to the United States, appropriate legislation, security measures, and policy must be enacted and enforced to mitigate future acts of terrorism.... concerning security issues....
8 Pages (2000 words) Report

Active Citizenship and Development

Both together aid a fundamental thread of communal cohesion and civic rejuvenation as are the aspects of local security.... … Active Citizenship – A Literature ReviewActive Citizenship basically refers to active civic participation.... It is an extremely essential concept for both the rejuvenation of civil society as well as for public governance....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us