StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Woodrow Wilson vs Henry Cabot Lodge - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper discuses the conflict and dispute between Mr. Woodrow Wilson, the Democrat President of USA and Henry Cabot Lodge, the Republican chairperson of the Senate Foreign relations Committee, in 1919 after WWI. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.9% of users find it useful
Woodrow Wilson vs Henry Cabot Lodge
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Woodrow Wilson vs Henry Cabot Lodge"

Essay, History and Political Science Essay, History and Political Science: Woodrow Wilson vs. Henry Cabot Lodge "After the First World War two dominant opinions regarding America’s future emerged. One envisioned by Woodrow Wilson and his League of Nations and the other by Henry Cabot Lodge and his independent America. Summarize both positions" October 08, 2013 Essay, History and Political Science: Woodrow Wilson vs Henry Cabot LodgE This paper discuses the conflict and dispute between Mr. Woodrow Wilson, the Democrat President of USA and Henry Cabot Lodge, the Republican chairperson of the Senate Foreign relations Committee, in 1919 after WWI.

The arguments were about the League of Nations that was formed as a part of the 1919 Treaty of Versailles. This paper summarizes the augments and positions of both personalities. The discussion will also examine the vision that was most appropriate for the US in 1919 and which is most appropriate for the US today. Summary of arguments by Mr. Wilson: Before WWI USA lived in a state of isolation, separated as it was from Europe by the great ocean and it did adopted the policy of 'isolationism'.

Britain and other European nations forced many trade restrictions on USA in a bid to curb its influence. During WWI, USA did not initially join the war and it only joined later and sided with the allies and its participation turned the tide and the allies won the war. President Wilson wanted to make use of this newfound status as a powerful force and supported the League of Nations. The League was a formal group of nations that had the main mission of maintaining peace and avoiding wars. As per the treaty of Versailles in 1919, Wilson proposed 14 principles.

The league did not have its own army but depended on armed forces from member nations. In case of conflict, wars and persecution of minorities, the league could ask member nations to send forces. Wilson, fresh from the success of WWI and the proved American dominance wanted his country to actively join the league and take up policing of peace initiatives across the world. His argument was that by becoming the torchbearer of peace, USA could dominate world politics, interfere in disputes, control trade and become a leading power, overthrowing even UK and USSR that had become a communist nation.

While world peace was the supposed main motive, US dominance of world politics was the 'hidden agenda' of Mr. Wilson (Brands, 23-26). Summary of arguments of Mr. Cabot: The Republican Senate member Mr. Cabot was against the one of the main principles of the 14 principles and this was that member nations had to 'mandatorily' send forces to assist other members. The argument of the senator was that Mr. Wilson did not consult him and other senate members while making these commitments and further that the US senate alone had the power to decide when to send forces to aid other nations.

His vision for USA was to take the nation back to isolation and keep away from the world politics. He also insisted that USA should have a veto power so that this power can be exercised to either support a cause or stop the league from acting against any cause that would harm USA allies or its interests. Mr. Lodge argues that USA was the savior and best hope for the world. However, if USA began interfering in the quarrels and fights of other nations, then it would be tangled in the murky affairs of Europe that were filled with petty intrigues and that resulted in WWI.

His argument was that American sovereignty would suffer and US forces would be available to quarrelsome nations across the world. He wanted the treaty amended so that his points and considerations were included (Hewes, 246-247). Appropriate vision for US in 1919 and now: the net result was that due to the objections of Mr. Lodge, the democrats, USA fell out of the treaty, and the League of Nations was formed without USA. This meant that the League was toothless, without any army and it could not enforce peace.

This led to the disastrous WWII and a further realigning of global politics and formation of the United Nations Organization with its own army. The appropriate vision for the League of Nations in 1919 should have been similar to the one that UNO has adopted. Mr. Wilson should have backed down and accepted some of the arguments and recommendations made by the Democrats and Mr. Lodge. Such an action would have given the League sufficient enforcing power, helped to restrict Hitler and allowed USA to remain independent while retaining its veto and dominant position (Northedge, 67-69).

By not allowing this to happen, Wilson and Lodge allowed other communist super powers such as Russia and China to become political influencers who have many times challenged American dominance in regions such as North Korea, Afghanistan, Vietnam, Pakistan, Cuba and other regions. This vision also holds true in the current situation where USA still dominates large areas of the globe and has some leverage in controlling trade and market (Kaniut, 53-56). References Brands, Howe. Six Lessons for the Next President, Lesson 5: Leave Under a Cloud.

New York: Hauenstein Center at Grand. 2008 Hewes, James. "Henry Cabot Lodge and the League of Nations". Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society (American Philosophical Society) 114. 4 (1970): 245–255 Kaniut, Ern. United Nations Reform: The need for legitimacy. PhD Thesis, Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey CA, USA. 1994. Northedge, Falstaff. The League of Nations: Its Life and Times, 1920–1946. NY: Holmes & Meier. 1986

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Woodrow Wilson vs Henry Cabot Lodge Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1487546-woodrow-wilson-vs-henry-cabot-lodge
(Woodrow Wilson Vs Henry Cabot Lodge Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/history/1487546-woodrow-wilson-vs-henry-cabot-lodge.
“Woodrow Wilson Vs Henry Cabot Lodge Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1487546-woodrow-wilson-vs-henry-cabot-lodge.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Woodrow Wilson vs Henry Cabot Lodge

U.S. History. The Steel Strike of 1919

henry cabot lodge Henry Cabot is best known for his stands on foreign policy, especially his 1919 war with President Wilson over the Versailles Treaty.... henry cabot is best known for his stands on foreign policy, especially his 1919 war with President Wilson over the Versailles Treaty.... HISTORY President woodrow wilson and Senator George Norris advanced opposing arguments about the question of American intervention in World War I.... Read their views in "woodrow wilson, an Address to the Joint Session of Congress, 1917" and "George Norris, 'A Speech in the Senate,' 1917" in Chapter 22 of the Documents Collection....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Collapse of Wilsonian World Order

The earliest origins of this word came from woodrow wilson who was the 28th president of the United States in the period after the severe damage of the World War I.... Theory The concept of “Wilsonism” came into being during the regime of woodrow wilson where he wrote fourteen points about the issue.... wilson believed that world democracies like the United States had the mandate of ensuring world stability.... In this respect it is important to understand the wilson new world order, its implications and why it collapsed (Dunwalke 2007, p....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Why did the United States fail to sign the Treaty of Versailles

henry cabot lodge and Alfred Beveridge were highly against the treaty.... President woodrow wilson was all set to sign the Treaty of Versailles and then enter the country into the League of Nations.... lodge was a Republican and the Senate majority leader and Chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee, thus holding a lot of power and responsibility.... History has paid substantial attention on the personal enmity that existed between Wilson and lodge, and, from the consequences that we have seen it is clear that there was, in fact, a lot of political animosity between them4....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

World War I - Why did the Senate choose to Ratify the Treaty of Versailles

The Treaty faced opposition from the United… henry cabot lodge, Chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee was the leader of those who had particular opposition to the League of Nations, which was The Treaty of Versailles, signed on June 28, 1919, was the result of a negotiation of the “Big Four” – Woodrow Wilson, British Prime Minister David Lloyd George, French Premier Georges Clemenceau and Vittorio Orlando of Italy.... henry cabot lodge, Chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee was the leader of those who had particular opposition to the League of Nations, which was an integral element of the Treaty....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Treaty of Versailles

The appointment of Winston Churchill as the First Lord of the Admiralty in England and the appointment of Franklin Delano Roosevelt as Assistant Secretary of the Navy by President woodrow wilson were the initial steps taken towards involving the United States in the war.... nbsp; Roosevelt is also on record that there is a conspiracy at least in the United States and that he was not excepting the wilson government....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Creation of League of Nations

hellip; The need of an international organization to maintain world peace and settle disputes by arbitration was felt by several world leaders such as woodrow wilson and Jan Smuts during the World War I.... The paper "Creation of League of Nations" deals with the role of the USA in the formation of the League of Nations....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Woodrow Wilson Wouldnt Yield by Thomas Bailey

Even henry cabot lodge, the Republican senator from Massachusetts, had already spoken publicly in favor of a league of nations.... henry cabot lodge (Ph.... Wilson did not have much respect for the “bungalow-minded” senators, and if he took one, the logical choice would be henry cabot lodge.... … The paper "woodrow wilson Wouldn't Yield" is an outstanding example of a history book review.... woodrow wilson's stubbornness and arrogance created a hostile Congress that would not allow his League of Nation to pass....
1 Pages (250 words) Book Report/Review

The Diplomatic Skills of Woodrow Wilson

… The paper "The Diplomatic Skills of woodrow wilson" is a great example of a politics research paper.... The paper "The Diplomatic Skills of woodrow wilson" is a great example of a politics research paper.... nbsp;"Missionary diplomacy," as Arthur Link has referred to wilson's foreign-policy efforts in the western hemisphere, was highlighted by American misadventures in Mexico.... nbsp;"Missionary diplomacy," as Arthur Link has referred to wilson's foreign-policy efforts in the western hemisphere, was highlighted by American misadventures in Mexico....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us