StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Slavery: a Necessary Evil or a Positive Good - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Slavery: a Necessary Evil or a Positive Good" is about The proslavery politicians and theorists who believed that though slavery is an evil to the colored people, abolition of this institution was a greater evil to all of the white society in America…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.1% of users find it useful
Slavery: a Necessary Evil or a Positive Good
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Slavery: a Necessary Evil or a Positive Good"

During the pre-Civil War period, slavery as a “necessary evil” was the southern white society’s assumptive moral premise for ratifying the institution in order to secure the supply of cheap slave labor for the South’s plantation-based economy. Yet partly, this proslavery premise was the southern white society’s racial fear and distrust for the black people. The southern white society feared that the emancipation of black slaves would create more harmful economic and social havoc than the evil of slavery. Therefore even though slavery is an evil, they believed that it is a necessary one. In 1820, Thomas Jefferson mentioned in a letter: “We have the wolf by the ear, and we can neither hold him nor safely let him go. Justice is in one scale, and self-preservation in the other.” But the reality was totally different. Since the slaves were constitutionally accredited citizens of the country, they were not sheltered by the legal system of the country. Therefore they frequently became subjects to torture and cruelty. Killing a slave for any kind of defiance was very common.

Therefore in the face of increasing opposition against slavery in the North, the Southerners had to take resort to Calhoun’s “positive good” theory. Indeed Calhoun’s “slavery as positive good” premise was a color-based defense for slavery. The southerner’ gradual failure to provide fresh blood to the “slavery as a necessary evil” theory compelled them to resort to white supremacy over black people with a view to sustaining their economic growth. In Southern America slaves were held primarily for economic purposes; but along the passage of time, slavery became a crucial part of the colonizer’s economy and became socio-economically into the early American society. “Blackness” itself as an ideology was critical for the exploitation of the labor of the African blacks in early America, and it “provided the very source of whiteness and the heart of racism”.

Indeed the “Compromise of 1850” and “the Fugitive Slave Act, 1850” were two major turning points in the debate over slavery. After the enforcement of “the Fugitive Slave Act, 1850” the South had no other legal barrier to continuing slavery. On the other hand, the north was legally bound to assist the slave-hunters. Indeed it was a disaster for both the slaves and the abolitionist north. It was a disaster for the north not only morally but also economically. A huge number of fugitive Negroes who were filling in the north’s free market, fled to Canada, making the economy unstable. The most disastrous effect of the Act was that even a free Negro, if claimed by a white, had been returned to the South as a slave. Since the Southerners were in advantage legally, the abolitionists had to take refuge in moral debate. Thus the legal debate over slavery turned into a moral one. Though the Southerners supported their proslavery stance from a moral viewpoint long before the Compromise of 1850, they had to depend on moral arguments for slavery intensively after enforcement of the 1850 Fugitive Act. In fact, the main source of moral support for slavery was biblical references that could sway the mind of the mass commoners in the South.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Examine the proslavery arguments. Why did white southerners change Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1589340-examine-the-proslavery-arguments-why-did-white-southerners-change-their-perception-from-believing-slavery-to-be-a-necessary-evil-to-believing-it-to-be-a-positive-good-discuss-the-fact-that-by-1850-the-national-debate-on-slavery-had-changed-from-being
(Examine the Proslavery Arguments. Why Did White Southerners Change Essay)
https://studentshare.org/history/1589340-examine-the-proslavery-arguments-why-did-white-southerners-change-their-perception-from-believing-slavery-to-be-a-necessary-evil-to-believing-it-to-be-a-positive-good-discuss-the-fact-that-by-1850-the-national-debate-on-slavery-had-changed-from-being.
“Examine the Proslavery Arguments. Why Did White Southerners Change Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1589340-examine-the-proslavery-arguments-why-did-white-southerners-change-their-perception-from-believing-slavery-to-be-a-necessary-evil-to-believing-it-to-be-a-positive-good-discuss-the-fact-that-by-1850-the-national-debate-on-slavery-had-changed-from-being.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Slavery: a Necessary Evil or a Positive Good

African American history assessing the antebellum slavery

Slave trade was viewed by slave masters as necessary evil because there was sparse population and therefore they needed labor to work in their farms.... Lack of education was also contributed to by the fact that the slaves no property that could help them subsidize for a good education.... This slavery is viewed as the highest degree of aristocracy.... As per the nature of work done, slavery involved involuntary servitude.... Human nature coupled with inequality in power is the greatest factor that influenced slavery....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The History of Slavery

This natural law approach to defending the existence of institutional slavery was countered by abolitionist movements primarily in the Northern states, who disputed the South's claim that not only was slavery a “necessarily evil” but a “positive good” (Norton, Sheriff and Katzman 233).... The apparent contradiction of slavery's development in America, the world's first democratic republic, is certainly difficult to understand, especially living in times where slavery is perceived as the most heinous moral crime....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The American Declaration of Independence

Speaking on the subject of "American slavery," he says he does not hesitate to declare, being identified with the American bondman, that the character of America never looked blacker to him than this Fourth of July" (Douglass, 1852).... The American Declaration of Independence is a document signed by thirteen Colonies declaring themselves independent of the Kingdom of Great Britain and ratified by the Continental Congress on July 4, 1776 (Wikipedia 2005)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Eugene Genovese's book Roll, Jordan, Roll: The World The Slaves

he subtlety of Genovese's argument can be seen as he sates that "southern paternalism, like every other paternalism, had little to do with Ole Massa's ostensible benevolence, kindness and good cheer .... Genovese suggests that slavery was not a one-dimensional torture chamber with the black slaves as absolute good and the white slave-owners as absolute evil, but rather it was a complex human institution made up of various cultural, social, political and economic elements....
16 Pages (4000 words) Book Report/Review

Historical Interpretation of Slavery

The paper "Historical Interpretation of slavery" highlights that in the light of the North/South divide, commerce, industry, religion, and – especially racism – they both give an honest and graphic description of slavery in nineteenth-century America.... The unwillingness of the central government to take action against slavery did little to improve a lot of slaves, indeed Thomas Jefferson – soon after writing the 'Declaration of Independence' maintained that while slavery was wrong he could see no 'practicable way' of removing it (Jefferson, 1820)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

William Blakes Poetry

In the poem, the capital sins are regarded by Blake as good things to God: pride is glory, lust is bounty, wrath is wisdom, and nakedness if the work of God.... This then somehow creates a pattern where the succeeding lines illustrate the same polarities between evil and good which are actually the same....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

In Favor of Slavery Abolition

Slave-owners presented slavery as a 'positive good' and economically beneficial institution.... This paper "In Favor of slavery Abolition" focuses on the history of slavery, its effect on the political and social split of the nation.... The author takes into account the arguments of the South against the abolition of slavery, its detrimental effects, ideals declared in The Declaration of Independence.... slavery became a real plague for the USA, undermining its basic ideological foundations....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper

Philosophy the Power of Ideas

Everything good and real comes from God.... According to Augustine, evil does not exist on its own and that there are two kinds of evil.... Natural evil is the absence of reality and since God is all that is real, natural evil is the absence of God.... Moral evil is turning away from God and his teaching....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us