StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The industrial revolution and economic opportunities for women in the 1830s - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the paper “The industrial revolution and economic opportunities for women in the 1830’s” the author analyzes two essays on this issue. This issue is important because gender matters are prioritized in the current world and hence it is prudent to highlight where society previously failed to avoid a repeat…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.1% of users find it useful
The industrial revolution and economic opportunities for women in the 1830s
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The industrial revolution and economic opportunities for women in the 1830s"

Insert The industrial revolution and economic opportunities for women in the 1830’s? The two essays on this issue try to answer whether the industrial revolution was of economic benefit to women in the 1830’s. This issue is important because gender matters are prioritized in the current world and hence it is prudent to highlight where society previously failed to avoid a repeat. On this, Nancy F. Cott argues that because of the industrial revolution, economic opportunities for “women opened up outside the home” (149) in the industry, journalism and to a limited extent in medicine, law, and business.

On the contrary, Gerda Lerner argues that much as more economic opportunities became available to women, they were alienated from the vital centers of economic opportunity. Lerner is the winning author as his perspective includes an evaluation of the impact of the jobs. Concerning what effects the revolution had on the lives of women, Lerner points out that professionalization “worked to the detriment of women” (152). She stated that when the need to train individuals in medicine arose, women were locked out of the recruitment process.

This happened with total disregard to the fact that prior to that some aspects of medicine as if women dominated the one midwifery. It was the case with law, business, and retail trade where the role of women diminished. Lerner further asserts that “the only reason women continued to thrive” (153) in two particular fields, nursing and education was actual because these areas were considered womanly and were in essence low paying. Aside from professionalization, Lerner argues that industrialization sharpened the divide in the lifestyle of women of different classes.

According to her, while the lower-class women essentially became ‘mill girls’ owing to their nature of work in factories, the middle and upper classes of women transformed to become ‘ladies’. This is because they invested their newfound free time in pursuing leisure. What comes out clearly from Lerner’s arguments is that the opportunities that arose from the industrial “revolution marginalized women” (155) and those that did not, were low-paying and long-hour jobs that did not present women with a better economic opportunity.

On the other hand, the supporting essay by Cott states that in “the 1830 is a primarily female labor force” (149) was recruited by new textile industries. According to Cott, this put money in the hands of women and the younger ones especially have to enjoy some degree of financial independence. Further, Cott highlights that a “greater number of women pursued primary school teaching,” (148) as it was the only profession open to them. Consequently, secondary school and academies where teachers were tutored increased resulting in improved literacy among women.

It is this improved literacy in women that Cott attributes the swelling numbers of female fiction writers and female journalists to. In addition, Cott argues that even with the professionalization of medicine, society was not ready to accept male midwives. As a result, midwifery remained as a preserve of women. In conclusion, Cott’s argument falls short as she fails to address the impact of the economic opportunities created. The industrial revolution indeed did create more jobs for women but these opportunities turned out to be of less economic significance as they were low paying and tiresome.

By highlighting the impact value of these jobs from an economic perspective, Lerner manages to come out as the persuasive of the two authors. Works Cited Cott, Nancy F. The Bonds of Womanhood. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1997. Print. Lerner, Gerda. The Lady and the Mill Girl. [Andover, Mass.]: [Warner Modular Publications], 1973. Print.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The industrial revolution and economic opportunities for women in the Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1701358-the-industrial-revolution-and-economic-opportunities-for-women-in-the-1830s
(The Industrial Revolution and Economic Opportunities for Women in the Essay)
https://studentshare.org/history/1701358-the-industrial-revolution-and-economic-opportunities-for-women-in-the-1830s.
“The Industrial Revolution and Economic Opportunities for Women in the Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1701358-the-industrial-revolution-and-economic-opportunities-for-women-in-the-1830s.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The industrial revolution and economic opportunities for women in the 1830s

Murder and Memories

Stowe was the first licensed woman doctor in the whole of Canada, and this offered more opportunities for women.... During the early 1890s, Canada's industrial revolution came in full force.... Canadians also passed legislation for protecting working women.... In the year 1885, Canadians extended the franchise to married women to own lowly valued property....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Japanese art influence on Western culture

The Japanese art contributed to the development of modern Western architectures, which were reminiscent later in the industrial revolution.... The exposure of Japanese to the economic opportunities in the West, and an influx of European philosophies, and culture into Japan have reversed the otherwise classic isolated Japanese artists.... The exposure of Japanese to the economic opportunities in the West, and an influx of European philosophies, and culture into Japan have reversed the otherwise classic isolated Japanese artists....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Related events and developments that span the years 1865 to the present

The important events outlined in this paper reveal the increasing participation of women in the labor market and the continuous shrinking of the pay gap between female and male employees.... The Historical Struggle of women towards Equality Latisha Barker HIS 204: American History Fiona Mani September 16, 2013 The Historical Struggle of women towards Equality The 19th Amendment, which legitimized and protected women's suffrage rights, and the Equal Pay Act are two of the most important events that have resulted in the promotion of gender equality in the contemporary workplace....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Pre First World War: 1914

Curling tongs were often used by many women in curling their hair.... In the early 1900s, pads and frames of false hair were common with women who wanted their hair to appear full and soft.... A Marie Stuart frame gave women a heart shaped Elizabethan look once the frame was covered with natural or false hair.... The zealous maids of these women sometimes overheated the curling tongs, which lead to singed heads.... women had to sit attached to this machine for up to 12 hours so as to achieve permanent curls....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Industrial Revolution, New Deal, WWI, WWII, and Feminism

The author answers questions about the industrial revolution, WWI, WWII, and Feminism.... The major innovations during the industrial revolution included the steam engine and weaving engine.... The financial industry and its rapid growth also characterized the industrial revolution as one of its core elements.... the industrial revolution began with an increased number of industries within European societies and spread to other parts of the world....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Wages Historically between Men and Women in the U.S

The perceived disparities exist in the percentages of men and women in the labor markets, the choice of occupations among men and… Although the issue of economic gender disparity become a prominent issue between the 1960s and the 1970s owing to the various women activists' organizations, the issue has been critical ever since the 1890s (Catherine et al, 385).... The number of women in the job markets in 1890s was around 15% (aged between 25 and40), and has significantly increased in the 2000s, where 76% are incorporated in the job market, as compared to 93% of men (Mokyr, 243)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Admission/Application Essay

Importance of the Financial Sector

The paper deals with the ways through which the local financial institutions can contribute to abolishing poverty and stimulating economic growth into the nations.... The study involves illustrations from real life so that the reader can figure out the paper's reliability.... hellip; This research will begin with the statement that financial sector comprises the most vital segment among all contributors to an economy's future growth mechanism....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Addressing the Issue of Underdevelopment Among Countries

The paper "Addressing the Issue of Underdevelopment Among Countries" identifies the causes of low levels of development present in certain countries.... The writer will focus on the social factors that contribute to the problem, particularly the issue of population growth.... hellip; If there is one thing that every country in this world strives to achieve then it is development....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us