StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

In Defense of Astrology Article - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "In Defense of Astrology Article" describes that the author needs to provide more information about why astrology is reliable and effective. In order to prove that astrology can be effective, one needs to provide more sources such as historical or scientific proof. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.2% of users find it useful
In Defense of Astrology Article
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "In Defense of Astrology Article"

The article “In Defense of Astrology” attempts to establish the notion that astrology should be taken as a serious art because it is more reliable and efficacious than a medical diagnosis. The author supports this claim with the following five arguments to show that astrology is efficacious: astrology has been practiced for over six-thousand years, Michel Gauqelin, a noted French statistician, established the truths of several claims, Jean Dizon, a noted astrologer, predicted that John F. Kennedy would be assassinated, ninety-six participants in a survey reported that astrology is accurate in predicting personality types, and psychologists use astrology when conducting diagnoses. Although these are all relevant considerations, the author’s key premises do not fully support the claim that astrology is a reliable source and that it should be taken more seriously as an art. This paper contains an analysis of each sub-argument and suggests how these arguments could be strengthened.

These sources could include official documents or ancient artifacts; however, the arguer does not provide anything to back up their argument and thus we must dismiss it for this reason alone. For example, in Korea over 1000 years ago, rulers from the Koryo dynasty used astrology as a political reference and this was an accepted practice at that time. If the arguer had provided these kinds of documents, then their argument would have been stronger and would have been taken more seriously.

            The argument that astrology needs to be taken more seriously as art and science come from Michel Gauquelin, a noted French statistician who established the truth of claims that proved a relationship between the planet Mars and outstanding athletes. The argument was based on athletes performing outstandingly in their discipline due to the position of Mars. This is a really bad argument because we cannot say that astrology is a reliable source just because the argument is based only on this example. The arguer generalizes the topic using this one example. Also, I know that famous people are well-respected, but that doesn’t mean that astrology is a dependable source just because of this French statistician. The author needs to find more information to come up with a convincing argument.      

            The claim that the predictions that astrologers make have high rates of success is a weak argument. Jeanne Dizon, a noted astrologer, predicted the assassination of President John F. Kennedy, but this does not mean that the event occurred just because she predicted it. Again, the arguer attempts to generalize based on only one example. They could have a stronger argument by providing more examples of predictions that were made and were then proved to be true. There is a high chance that this prediction was a one-off and may not happen again in the future.

             The fourth argument is based on the claims of a study that ninety-six percent of participants surveyed reported that astrology could be an accurate predictor of personality. The arguer tried to back up their claim with the twelve-sign system of astrology, but this cannot be considered as firm evidence. The arguer commits the genetic fallacy—there is no evidence to support their claim. They mentioned one study; however, we need to know what this study is and where it came from. Otherwise, this claim doesn’t support this argument very strongly. Also, the arguer needs to provide more information about the twelve-sign system of astrology. We cannot believe astrology is accurate just because of the twelve-sign system because it has not yet been proven statistically significant. 

            The final argument suggests that astrology is effective in psychological diagnoses and treatments because some psychologists use astrology to treat their patients. The arguer tries to support this claim by saying that studies have proven this to be true, but the arguer does not provide any evidence of such studies. If astrology is used in medical treatment, then it may have an effect, but there is no evidence that psychologists who use astrology are more effective in treating their patients. The arguer needs more specific information to back up their claim. This argument is not convincing enough based on the claims given by the arguer. 

            Each of the supporting arguments rests on an undefended and questionable claim or a false assumption. The author’s arguments are relevant but are not sufficient enough to establish their case.   

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Logic and thought Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 words - 1”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/other/1428455-logic-and-thought
(Logic and Thought Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words - 1)
https://studentshare.org/other/1428455-logic-and-thought.
“Logic and Thought Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/other/1428455-logic-and-thought.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF In Defense of Astrology Article

Convention Rights and the UK Law

Private in the sense that article 8 protects it.... If yes, the second query arises: must the interest of the holder of the private information or data yield to the right of freedom of expression granted on the publisher by article 10?... Key Strasbourg Case law: Von Hannover v Germany (2005) 40 EHRR 1, ECtHR The issue was whether German courts infringed on Princess Caroline of Monaco's right to respect of her private life under article 8.... Therefore, article 8 had been violated (DeCew 1997)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Neo-Roosevelt, or Why Post-Colonialism Is Premature

Thomas E Woods has contributed numerous times to the publication, and is also the ongoing author of "Church and the Market," a news publication dealing with Catholicism and religious reasoning in defense of a free world economy.... The paper is a scathing article showing an angry and despondent Twain writing to friends and family condemning God and the Bible as far, far inferior to Science and the physics of astrology.... The article gives a detailed account of exactly how/why/when Mark Twain openly supported the idea of increasing trade and acquiring land from Hawaii, and mainland China. ...
8 Pages (2000 words) Annotated Bibliography

Organopathy and Its Relation to Homeopathy

e/dw/article/0,1564,1575855,00.... This link to the occult and mysticism is probably because its founder, Paracelsus is a well known wise man who delved into astrology, various natural sciences, medicine etc.... Organopathy traces its origins to Paracelsus, a well known wise man who dealt in alchemy, medicine, astrology and in the occult (Paracelsus, 2005).... Paracelsus being an astrologer also tried to tie up medicine with astrology, arguing that somehow the heavenly bodies exert an influence on the health of persons (Monk-Schenck, 2002)....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Changing Role of Women

The article "Changing Role of Women" includes this anthology deals with the various aspects of changed role of women in the transformed society and age as women in the modern age has been a relevant and valuable topic in feminist theory relating to the sex inequalities and gender role differences.... He in the article "From Emancipation to Liberation: The Changing role of Women in Turkey's Public Realm" which has been the first essay of the anthology, deals with the changed role of women in the public sector of Turkey....
9 Pages (2250 words) Article

Aetiology of Criminal Violent Behaviour

The articles were selected based on their authenticity, the source and journal of publication, the citations of the article itself and the quality of the citations and references included within the article.... The significant articles that matched the need for the article composition and research were included and the remaining were excluded from the references.... ddition of new material and revision of the article.... Inclusion of reference list and planning of the format of the article....
10 Pages (2500 words) Literature review

Comparing the Difference between Duress and Insanity

The defense of duress is easier to prove according to Gorr (2000) because there are more tangible circumstances.... om/law-library/article/criminal-defenses.... This research gives an understanding of the "Twinkie defense" and "temporary insanity" defenses as well as cases to show the difference between the two.... An individual with a duress defense must prove that they committed a crime because someone else threatened them with bodily harm....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

The Defence of Poesy by Sir Philip Sidney

defense of poesy.... Basically, in this article, Sir Phillip Sidney discusses in-depth the significance of poetry.... Basically, in this article Sir Phillip Sidney discusses in-depth on the significance of poetry.... He notes that, in case Pugliano's affections and arguments concerning his vocation as a horseman may not be satisfactory, he will provide a strong defence for his vocation as a poet in this article.... Therefore, in this article he sets out to defend poesy and show to readers how the significance of poetry....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Issues Relating to Contract Formation and Breach of Contract

He informed her that he would not pay her for a lecture on astrology.... Ben thought that Sharon was an astronomer, due to her name being listed under astronomy, whilst Sharon thought that she would be delivering a lecture on astrology.... "Issues Relating to Contract Formation and Breach of Contract" paper examines the case of Ian, who rejected the offer made by Ben, to deliver a lecture to the latter's class, due to the assumption that a better offer was available on the same date for some other party....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us