StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Interpretations of Crossan Would Not Negatively Impact on Christianity - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Interpretations of Crossan Would Not Negatively Impact on Christianity" states that Crossan’s interpretations of the Gospels would enrich the teachings of the Christianity on Jesus Christ, their founder, by bringing to right some knowledge on the life of Jesus that we weren’t aware of…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.2% of users find it useful
Interpretations of Crossan Would Not Negatively Impact on Christianity
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Interpretations of Crossan Would Not Negatively Impact on Christianity"

?Henry Nabea # Religion and Theology 19th April. Analysis and Interpretation In his book, Jesus: A Revolutionary Biography, Dominic Crossan critically and radically challenged the traditional view of Jesus of Nazareth. Crossan subjected the four Gospels into critical evaluation and he employed the method of historical criticism in his attempt to find out whether the main Gospel claims are based on factual matters or not. In the final analysis Crossan challenged and refuted many biblical accounts on Jesus Christ in the Gospel. For instance, he laid bare the many inconsistencies in the biblical account on the Birth of Jesus Christ, and he went on to show that the accounts are spurious and not based on historical facts (Crossan, 1-25). In this book, Crossan also claimed that Jesus Christ was a critic of the tradition that he inherited, and that, he would, most likely, critic how Christianity has interpreted him for the last two millennia. But what impacts would Crossan’s interpretation of the Bible have on the traditional view of Jesus Christ? Would Crossan’s interpretation of the Bible weaken the Christians faith in Jesus Christ, or would it make the Christian’s faith in Jesus Christ stronger? Would Christianity stand if Crossan’s interpretation of the Bible is correct? These are the questions that this paper answers. While Crossan’s interpretation of the Gospels undoubtedly challenges and refutes some Christian dogmas that form the basis of Christian believes in Jesus Christ, the interpretation would not, however, substantially change the Christians’ traditional image of Jesus Christ, or weaken their faith in Jesus. We would still be Christians even if Crossan were right. There are a number of reasons why Crossan’s interpretations of the Gospels would not substantially affect the Christian’s faith in Jesus Christ or alter Christianity in any substantial way. To begin with, it is important to note that most of the refutations that Crossan make on the Gospels, are on the historical aspect of the Gospel, whether or not the Gospel constitutes an historical account of what, actually, took place in the Life of Jesus Christ. And in his investigations, Crossan concluded that most of what we are told of Jesus Christ is not a historical account of what happened, but rather, a skewed account of what the writers of the Gospels wanted us to hear and to believe (Crossan, Prologue xiii-x1v). Crossan goes on to argue that Christian’s faith is merely a belief in the historical Jesus as the manifestation of God ( Crossan, 244). But while the Christians would be surprised to know that what they have all along believed is not based on historical facts, this would not substantially affect their traditional image of Jesus Christ or their faith in Jesus because, faith is not merely based on historical facts. Faith rather is a deep spiritual experience that is not based on historical data. Sheliermacher concurs with this view when he asserts that faith is a’’ feeling’’ (Alvarez, n.d). What Alvarez essentially means in this quotation is that faith is more than dogmas, and it is a deep personal experience. Faith in Jesus Christ, therefore, is a spiritual experience, and although historical facts acts as some basis of our faith, once one has a spiritual experience of Jesus Christ, a change in historical data or dogmas would not substantially affect one’s faith. Even with the interpretations of Crossan, therefore, the Christians would have the traditional image of Jesus Christ as the son of God. This fact is corroborated more by Clifford in his view of Religion as an evolving phenomenon‘’ Religion as Cultural System’’ (Clifford, 88). Since from earliest stages of man, in the Stone Age, man has exhibited some religious tendencies, and human Religion as a human phenomenon has undergone many changes within the course of history. This anthropological fact shows that even with the disapproval of many historical accounts of Jesus Christ in the Gospels, the Christian faith would undergo some kind of evolution, and this evolution would not make Christianity to be dismissed by the Christians. Christians would still keep their faith in Jesus Christ, but with some modifications. But these modifications would not substantially impact negatively on Christianity as a Religion as to alter the traditional image of Jesus Christ among the Christians. Secondly, Crossan’s interpretation on the Gospels of Jesus Christ would not weaken Christianity as a Religion because the main basis of Christian believes is not the literal meanings of the content of the Bible, but rather the message behind the literal meanings. The Bible is full of Myths and untrue stories that a meant as mere tools or instruments of communicating the message of God. For instance, the creation account that we find in the book of Genesis is purely a myth that is used to pass the vital message that God is the creator. But the account of creation given in the book of Genesis is no way an historical or scientific explanation of what actually happened during creation. But even though many Christians take this story of creation in the book of Genesis as a true account of creation, they, nonetheless, don’t lose their faith when they realize that the account isn’t a true explanation of how creation took place. They still continue to believe that God is the creator of the Universe. Even if Crossan’s interpretations were right, therefore, Christians wouldn’t lose their faith in Jesus Christ as the son of God because, this is the main message in the Gospels. Christianity would continue to survive even with Crossan’s interpretations of the Bible. Thirdly, Christianity is not based on false beliefs and some Christian denominations; the Catholic Church in particular, encourages its members to subject their beliefs into critical reasoning. The Catholic Church teaches that faith and reason do not conflict, and it even allows historical criticism, the method that was used by Crossan, in terpreting the Bible (Alvarez, 6). So, the Church is not afraid of investigating even the truth behind what Crossan calls the ‘’ reconstructed historical Jesus’’ (Crossan, 223). The Catholic Church is of the view that truth, whether scientific, historical, or any other form of truth will enhance its teachings rather than weaken it. This in essence means that the historical findings on biblical matters should enrich and strengthen the teachings of the Church, instead of weakening it. In conclusion, we would still remain Christians even if the interpretations of Crossan were right. Christianity as a Religion would remain intact. Although the interpretations would be met by surprise and disbelief by the Christians, the interpretations would not substantially affect the faith of the Christians. The interpretations of Crossan would neither negatively impact on Christianity, nor would it spur interest in Christianity and lead to more people becoming Christians. Crossan’s interpretations of the Gospels would, however, enrich the teachings of the Christianity on Jesus Christ, their founder, by bringing to right some knowledge on the life of Jesus that we weren’t aware of. Works Cited Alhavez, D.’’ Study of Religion Handout, Part 1: 1800-1900’’. n.d. Print Ibid. ,, Part 11: 1860-1960. ,, ,, Crossan, J.D. Jesus: A Revolutionary Biography. USA, San Francisco: Harper, 1994. Web. Cliford, G.’’ Religion as a Cultural System’’. Oxford: Fontana Press, 1993. Web. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“FINAL EXAM FIRST ESSAY Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
FINAL EXAM FIRST ESSAY Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1473529-final-exam-first-essay
(FINAL EXAM FIRST ESSAY Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
FINAL EXAM FIRST ESSAY Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1473529-final-exam-first-essay.
“FINAL EXAM FIRST ESSAY Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1473529-final-exam-first-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Interpretations of Crossan Would Not Negatively Impact on Christianity

The Analysis of the Marriage of Heaven and Hell by William Blake

He challenges christianity as it is practiced by the established Church by asserting that the authorities have limited appreciation of God, and at the same time he holds Bible in high esteem, which he believes contains spiritual revelations.... William Blake: His Personal Mythology William Blake contests the practices of christianity, and to fill the vacuum of faith, he devises a substitute in the form of personal mythology.... This is the area of strongest objection to christianity by Blake....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Unlocking the postcolonial experience with the keys of history

In my reading of history I have found that the meaning of history is different for different people.... n other words any history,which includes also the postcolonial one,has a subjective meaning for the individual.... owever,an objective approach to history can unlock the impasse of interpretation of history to the reasonable satisfaction of all people....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Early medieval history of Ireland

With the fall of the Roman Empire, much of Western Europe lost its scholarship as christianity tended to withdraw into its own sanctuaries.... Splendid reminders of early Irish christianity can be found in the stone, high crosses that melded the country's pagan roots with the newly imported faith.... With the fall of the Roman Empire, much of Western Europe lost its scholarship as christianity tended to withdraw into its own sanctuaries.... Splendid reminders of early Irish christianity can be found in the stone, high crosses that melded the country's pagan roots with the newly imported faith....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

Well-Being in the Religious Community

clergy in the modern era, by exploring the association of health with the services rendered by the religious people to the members of society for… One of the most significant reasons behind conducting the research on the above-described topic includes the tremendous rise in the issues and problems concerned with the health of the individuals during the contemporary era, where the diagnosis and spread of fatal diseases in almost all regions of the globe have created grave challenges for the political, social and cultural authorities on the one side, and for the people associated with the fields and professions of religious services on the other....
93 Pages (23250 words) Thesis

Medical Ethics in Palliative Care

Practitioners of Jainism walk around with brushes with which they sweep ground in front of them; this is not out of a desire to keep the ground clean but rather to avoid stepping on and killing any insect that may happen to crawl in front of them.... To them all life is sacred,… espective of the species and people should do their utmost to preserve it, on the other extreme end there are the pro-choice activists who believe that people should have the right make choices whether on matters of their own death, or even that of their unborn children....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Church History from the Time of Reformation

After breaking the church unity, it made up the third largest christianity branch known as Protestantism.... This paper ''Church History from the Time of Reformation'' tells about the church is one of the institutions in the economic, political, and social fields that have experienced an immense reformation since the ancient periods....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Roman Catholic Faith vs Apostolic Faith

There developed struggles among the churches and the populations until the acceptance of christianity by Emperor Constantine marking it as a religion for the Roman Empire.... At this time, the Pentarchy of christianity marked by five primary items of Rome, Antioch, Alexandria, Jerusalem and Constantinople.... Considering the history, it is believed that Catholic was one of the founding blocks of christianity that is believed to have its roots to Jesus Christ....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Ancient vs Modern Apologetics

In terms of impact, the ancient apologetic erroneously seemed more impactful because there was little tolerance thus little criticism and rejection.... The essay "Ancient vs Modern Apologetics" discusses modern apologetics that varies from the ancient one in a number of ways including the framing of arguments....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us