Retribution in the Barrel of Amontillado
Corey Carson Mr. Mims Eng 102 Due 2/3/12 The wonderful preference of vengeance Retribution is not always as pleasant as it is cracked up to be. In Edgar Allan Poe’s narrative “The Cask of Amontillado” among the major personalities, Montresor systems to get revenge on the other major character in this story, Fortunato. According to Montresor, in order for him to be satisfied with the method he repays he should meet 2 conditions. Montresor states, “I must not just penalize, but penalize with immunity. A wrong is undressed when the avenger stops working to make himself felt as such to him who has done the incorrect. (Poe. 618) To put it simply, Montresor should get his revenge without being caught by any individual, however likewise as though the person versus whom the revenge is looked for, in this situation it’s Fortunadt, understands complete well that vengeance is being taken versus him. While Montresor does do well in luring Fortunato into the catacombs and also killing him, Montresor does not completely meet his needs regarding just how he intended to get his vengeance. Initially, Montresor states that he does not want to be captured by any individual.
We understand that this condition was met because the storyteller says, “There were no assistants in your home; they had made off to make merry in honor of the moment. I had actually told them that I should not return until the early morning, as well as had actually given them explicit orders not to mix from your home.” (Poe. 619) This was an important condition to be met because if Montresor did not inform the assistants of your house not to mix from your home his plan to draw Fortunato down with the catacombs to his fatality would have been jeopardized.
Montresor nonetheless does not completely be successful with the second problem that he set for himself. The reason why Montresor did not fully prosper is since Fortunato was not completely knowledgeable about why he was being punished. When Montresor first met his old close friend Fortunato he was currently heavily intoxicated as well as wearing motley. Montresor took advantage of Fortunato’s weakness by conveniently deceiving him right into his trap by attracting things that Fortunato recognizes most, red wine.
Montresor’s most significant failure was that Fortunato did not truly recognize why he was being penalized. Montresor got a little response from Fortunato however it was not the action he required to hear in order to understand that Fortunato comprehended why he was being punished for what he had actually done. As a matter of fact, Fortunato in fact thought that it was a joke that was being played on him. As Montresor started to walk away he listened to Fortunato weep out, “For the love of God, Montresor!” and he responded “Yes, For the love of God! (Poe. 623) Montresor obviously was not satisfied keeping that one last cry. Montressor was waiting for something extra such as Fortunato pleading for his life or begging for mercy for whatever he did to Montresor. One last reason that Montresor does not obtain his best revenge is since after Montresor walls Fortunato in as well as awaits a reaction after calling his name out several times Montresor listens to the ding of bells and after that states, “There appeared in return only a jingling of the bells.
My heart grew sick– on account of the moisture of the catacombs.” (Poe 623) This demonstrates how Montresor was not pleased with his end result but just brushes it off by saying it was the moisture of the catacombs that is making him really feel the way that he does. Montresor ultimately did not obtain the revenge that he had actually wanted to hop on Fortunato due to the fact that Montresor claims, “In pace requiescat.” (Poe 623) Which suggests may he relax in peace, which is what Fortunato did.
Fortunato did not know why he was being penalized which was one of Montresor’s two problems that he must satisfy. For Montresor ahead and also retell the story of his revenge on Fortunato so well in excellent information it almost appears as if Montresor was the one that was required to manage what he had done while Fortunato reached relax in tranquility without a disruption for 50 years. While Montresor did get his vengeance it was not what he had actually hoped it would be because he did not fully please what he intended to get out of his revenge story.