These 2 stories by Washington Irving and Nathaniel Hawthorne respectively, highlight different examples of males wandering away from house, for rather various reasons, with rather the exact same results with the exception of the overall result upon the males. Careful analysis of the two stories can reveal both the resemblances and the differences in between the two, and how those things are essential to the story as a whole.
Young Goodman Brown takes a look at the life of male after venturing into the woods in order to complete some unidentified errand in the middle of the night.
He comes across an old man who bears a somewhat chilling similarity of himself, in addition to a number of other townspeople that have some significance in his life. He reaches his destination, which appears to be some sort of routine, where he and his spouse, who is ironically named faith, are to be initiated into what can be assumed to be a witches coven, due to the witch trials that had actually occurred in the same town almost 150 years earlier.
Goodman Brown cries to heaven for salvation from this location, and the scene disappears.
The following day, after returning house, he has lost all faith in mankind, including his better half. He spends the rest of his life living in paranoia, for that reason, his “dying hour was gloom”. What we see in this story is a guy, who might or might not have dreamed the scene in which he participated, however nevertheless, he loses his entire faith in everything that he had actually formerly been taught. From his christianity to his faith in his marriage, everything breaks down in his mind. Hawthorne, known to discuss the hypocrisy of the puritan system, might have been using this story as a way to bring forth doubt in the minds of his readers and make them question the very foundation of the lifestyle of the puritans.
In the story of Rip Van Winkle, we see a guy, who was much enjoyed by the town for his good deeds, but not so much by his spouse for his objection to do effort on the farm, triggering their farm to fall into much chaos. One day, he leaves home with his pet to go squirrel searching in order to escape the nagging of his other half. He ventures up into the mountains and comes across some guys bring moonshine up the mountain. He follows them and encounters more males playing a game of nine-pins and drinking. Having no regard for what might take place, he begins to consume with them. He quickly goes to sleep, to awake nearly 20 years later, after the occurrence of the American Revolution.
He goes back to his village to find that nobody acknowledges him, except for his now grown daughter who takes him in. He resumes his previous life of stories and kind deeds, however never ever any effort. This story, apparently much less symbolic than Young Goodman Brown, still has a really valid point to make. This story indicate the concept that effort leads to prosperity, and preventing said work could result in a life that passes you by in an instant, resulting in a person unrecognizable to society.These two stories have lots of surface level similarities, but very glaring differences in the linked meaning of these stories. Both appear to reveal a guy, running away from home for a short time to complete some sort of errand.
Both likewise lead to the altering of stated man, although much less Rip Van Winkle, into something a little less desirable. Young Goodman Brown loses all faith in his life and humankind, therefore making the rest of his life unpleasant, and some may even state, unworthy living. Rip remains purchase and large the very same slacking person that he was, and some even called him blessed for missing the Transformation, however no doubt he had many difficult feelings about losing out on the raising of his kids and things of the sort. The stories however, approach the change in a really various way, particularly in the case of Young Goodman Brown.
This story highlights the dissent into this guy’s madness in a way that truly impacts the reader, and perhaps accomplishes Hawthorne’s goal of weakening the authority and legitimacy of the puritan system. The story particularly mentions locations of Goodman Brown’s life that he need to place skepticism in, therefore giving particular examples of corruption in the system. Rip van Winkle however, shows only the outcomes of the occasions that took place in the mountains that day, and just recap Rip’s capability to maintain his previous way of life, although with a significant portion missing. In general, I believe it would be easier to state that these stories are much more different than similar due to the fact that, despite the similar beginning occasions of each story, the plots take very different directions for really various factors, and tell much different stories as a whole.