StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Defining Rule utilitarianism - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Rule utilitarianism is a kind of utilitarianism which defines if an action should be considered to be ethical or not based on the idea of rule that the majority of the people has been following (Smart, 1973, 9). Hospers presents three examples of ethical dilemma. The first of…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.5% of users find it useful
Defining Rule utilitarianism
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Defining Rule utilitarianism"

Defining Rule utilitarianism Rule utilitarianism is a kind of utilitarianism which defines if an action should be considered to be ethical or not based on the idea of rule that the majority of the people has been following (Smart, 1973, 9). Hospers presents three examples of ethical dilemma. The first of them is focused on the following situation: ten people are stuck in a cave. They have two options: kill a fat man to safe nine of them of not kill him and all ten will die eventually. The second example deals with lying.

Thus, people always have an option of lying or refraining from this activity as there is no strict rule about that. Finally, Hospers brings up the last example when people vote. Thus, on an election day people may or may not be willing to go and vote. The first example might be considered to be an objection to act utilitarianism since according to it killing the fat man would be quite useful for the group of people, but the majority of people would agree on the fact that killing is wrong. The second example also shows that act utilitarianism might be regarded as a false approach: it is true that sometimes for a particular individual lying might bring considerable more benefits that tell the truth; however, the society condemns lying.

Finally, the third example may also be regarded as a valid claim that rebuts act utilitarianism. According to the latter, it would be more ethical not to vote for a person, but it is quite obvious that such approach would ruin the legal system. Rule utilitarianism would provide a different solution for this problem. In case of the fat man, it would encourage people to let that man live. The reason for this is quite simple: it is generally accepted that killing other people is not an ethical action.

That is why killing the person in question will violate the general rule which contributed to the security in the society. In the second example about lying, rule utilitarianism would urge a person to tell a truth even though it might be some problems. The logic behind it is rather simple: the social life is being productive and stable because people generally do not lie to each other. That is why if people chose to make an exception from that rule, they might undermine the very foundation of the society.

Finally, in the example of voting, rule utilitarianism would encourage people to go and vote in spite of the fact that they may not be willing as if all the other people chose not to vote this is likely to break the democratic system and result in the collapse of the government.In my opinion rule utilitarianism is much better theory as act utilitarianism because the latter is likely to bring chaos as the consequences of it are not controlled and might contributed to the destruction of the entire system of human relationships while rule utilitarianism is oriented at preserving the harmony among people.

ReferencesSmart, J. (1973). Utilitarianism; for and against. Cambridge: University Press.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Defining Rule utilitarianism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1665014-defining-rule-utilitarianism
(Defining Rule Utilitarianism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/social-science/1665014-defining-rule-utilitarianism.
“Defining Rule Utilitarianism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1665014-defining-rule-utilitarianism.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Defining Rule utilitarianism

Ethics of New Yorks Smoking Ban

In rule utilitarianism, a principle determines what is moral, and individual actions follow the general rules of morality.... In Act utilitarianism, an action determines what is moral, and general rules can be distilled from the act.... If the entire building is full of smokers, then the benefits outweigh the harm; hence the rule is unethical.... The two forms are Act and rule.... For example, if two people were in a burning building-say an elderly man and a small child-and you could only rescue one, you would rescue the child because she would have the higher potential for happiness in the future; the rule being that the higher degree of happiness wins out....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The theory of utilitarianism

utilitarianism theory is referred to by some as the consequentialist ethical theory.... utilitarianism theory is referred to by some as the consequentialist ethical theory.... The stronger of the two is so-called act-utilitarianism.... The second system is called rule-utilitarianism.... Rule-utilitarianism may be regarded as a weaker form of utilitarianism than act-utilitarianism....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Utilitarianism and Individual Rights and Justice

This paper analyzes how the utilitarianism approach will assess the permissibility of torturing the children, and if it can provide an acceptable conclusion.... It will first explain some of the main ideas of utilitarianism and then explore how utilitarianism would approach this… utilitarianism is based on the “general happiness principle” or the “principle of utility” (PU).... Among several actions, the right action promotes The assumptions of utilitarianism are: 1) Human well-being is a common good; 2) Everyone should be included in the assessment of utility; and 3) The right actions promote what is good for society....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

DETAILED COMPARISON BETWEEN ACT AND RULE UTILITARIANISM

Therefore, A DETAILED COMPARISON BETWEEN ACT AND rule utilitarianism Ethics is an area of study that comprises countless theories, based on doctrines of performing individual acts either right or wrong and good or bad.... wo forms of utilitarianism, act utilitarianism and rule utilitarianism are in conflict with each other.... Instead, rule utilitarianism, being an idealistic and inflexible theory, is based on rules involving conduct and related principles....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Philosophy: Utilitarianism Concept

Mill, a father of modern utilitarianism.... The author also examines two examples used by Kai Neilson to show philosophical tenets and the moral concept of utilitarianism Bernard Williams.... hellip; The earlier important narratives of utilitarianism, to which Mill frequently refers, are that of Epicurus, an ancient Greek philosopher, Bentham, and James Mill.... rdquo; Mill states this argument as a culmination of his condemnation of the critics of this theory who utilitarianism who interpret it grossly and “habitually express it in rejection of pleasure in some of its forms....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Values and Society - Utilitarianism

This review " Values and Society - utilitarianism" discusses the modern application of utilitarianism was just that, sterile, and that in the process we had all become robots to a theory that took the life out of everything, especially our appreciation of the arts.... hellip; utilitarianism as a concept seems at first a hard idea to argue one way or the other.... Because of his misgivings, it is hard to make further arguments for utilitarianism since Bentham himself sees problems in its application....
6 Pages (1500 words) Literature review

Just War Ethics Theories

This essay "Just War Ethics Theories" states that utilitarianism is the best theory that can be used to shed more light on the just war tradition in place of the usual deontological and virtue ethics perspectives.... hellip; There are various moral perspectives that can be used to explain the just war theory including virtue ethics, deontological and utilitarianism.... However, utilitarianism is the theory that is the most practical for explaining just war in the contemporary world....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Theory of Justice

The paper "Theory of Justice" supposes philosophers come up with different principles to define justices.... They all agree on the need to have justice in society.... With justice, there would be cohesion in society.... Society would thrive under just systems and individuals would achieve their well-being....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us