Paradox Evaluation of “The Barrel of Amontillado” In “The Cask of Amontillado” by Edgar Allan Poe, the main personality named Montresor is laid out for revenge. Montresor’s only issue is to get revenge on the guy that has wronged him named Fortuanto. Montresor never ever specifies why Fortunato should have to be penalized.
The only statement Montresor makes is that Fortunato “creates him a thousand injuries” till “venturing upon disrespect.” (Poe, Online) Montresor plans to obtain his revenge by hiding Fortunato to life. Montresor executes each detail while he smiles at his target.
Montresor doesn’t smile at the idea of Fortunato’s “immolation” however as a result of viciousness. (Sweet Jr. Online )Montresor smiles since he believes the sacrifice of Fortunato will certainly bring him a fantastic incentive. Fortunato is actually the “mirror self” of Montresor (Dessert Jr. Online). Montresor’s wish to bury Fortunato active”paints the emotional picture of repression” (Sugary food Jr. Online). The funeral of Fortunato represses Montresor’s evil nature and also puts him peaceful. In “The Barrel of Amontillado,” Edgar Allan Poe makes use of paradox to develop his motif of seeking salvation with suppression.
Poe makes use of Fortunato’s name paradoxically to symbolize one individuality in between Montresor and also Fortunato. Though Fortunato indicates “the privileged one” in Italian, Fortuanto satisfies an unfavorable fate as the sufferer Montresor’s overall retribution plot. (Stott, Online) Consequently, the Fortunato side of Montresor symbolizes ton of money. Montresor’s need is to repress Fortunato. Because “the love of loan is the origin of all wickedness,” a fortune would certainly “dive a guy right into mess up and devastation” (1Timothy 6:9 -10). The Fortunato side of Montresor’s personality wants to have riches.
The riches Fortunato gets makes him both appreciated and feared. (Poe, Online) By having riches, Fortunato triggers Montresor “a thousand injuries”(Poe, Online). When Fortunato’s wide range gets the worry of others, he “ventures upon disparaging God” (Poe, Online). When a “guy seeks greed for gain, he curses and relinquishes the Lord” (Psalms 10:3). Montresor needs to quelch Fortunato to secure his soul from damnation. (Stott, Online) The only method Montresor can protect himself is to do away with Fortunato. Montresor can repress the aspect of his character which dishonors God by hiding Fortunato alive.
Fortunato, ironically in spite of his name, faces a really unfortunate destiny through Montresor. Montresor’s name translation similar to Fortunato’s in 2 ways. In French Montresor’s name “combines the words montrer as well as kind meaning to reveal fate” (Clendenning, Online). Montresor reveals Fortunato his destiny yet Fortunato “obtains no articulation to a hazard” regarding his fate. (Poe, Online) When Montresor reveals Fortunato his fate of being hidden alive it demonstrates that Fortunato’s live funeral is an act of repression. The second French translation for Montersor is “my treasure”.
With punishing Fortunato Montresor thinks he can have the treasure of pureness and also salvation. Fortunato’s gown is paradoxical for a guy with his stature in culture. Fortunato is a guy with stature who is “abundant, respected, as well as appreciated” (Poe, Online). Fortunato puts on a “tight-fitting parti-striped dress, as well as his head is surmounted by the conelike cap as well as bells” for the carnival.” (Poe, Online). Instead of the cap standing for Christ’s crown of thorns, the cap represents Satan’s duty as “Prince of Fools” (Pittman, Online).
With the sacrifice of Jesus Christ, Christians were able to obtain redemption. With Fortunato’s sacrifice, Montresor will look for redemption. Montresor outfits extra like a clergyman for the carnival period. “Montresor’s black roquelaire signifies a clergyman’s black deal put on during a funeral mass.” (Cooney, Online) Montresor outfits for the event that he is going to hide Fortunato. Montresor’s outfit suggests that the suppression of Fortunato will certainly have an essential spiritual incentive. Through the repression of Fortunato, Montresor will certainly get to redemption.
The circus setting ironically suggests a time for sin. “The circus season consists of the last indulgences in the satisfaction of the flesh” (Pittman, Online). Fortunato’s wrong of abundantly drinking makes Montresor’s plan easy to carry out. “Words carnival can be equated in Italian significance to do away with the flesh which demonstrates symbolic irony of Montresor’s intent for Fortunato” (Clendenning, Online). Montresor can make himself free of transgression and also deserving of redemption by repressing the sinfulness of Fortunato. The catacombs are a paradoxical symbol of the way Montresor assumes.
The repression begins when Montresor takes Fortunato right into his family members catacombs with the guarantee of Amontillado white wine. The catacombs are “lined with human remains” which recommends generational family problems (Poe, Online). Fortunato maintains going further and also further into the catacombs with only his sinful ideas of having the ability to drink even more red wine, not recognizing he is relocating better as well as closer to his destiny of being hidden active. The wall signifies the surface of the suppression of Fortunato. “Ironically, the wall creates Fortunato’s burial crypt. (Sugary Food Jr., Online) Redemption can only occur when transgressions are repented. When Fortunato yells “For the love of God, Montresor!,” Montresor states “Yes, … for the love of God!” (Poe, Online). Montresor thinks that Fortunato’s repression reveals his love for God and demonstrates Montresor getting to salvation. The barrel represents an admission. Montresor tells the story fifty years later on in a confession tone. “When Montresor states, “You, that so popular the nature of my spirit,” he indicates a priest receives his confession” (Dessert Jr., Online).
Montresor believes that Fortunato’s funeral was done in excellent. Montresor has no regret as he admits yet, he still admits. “Montresor’s conscience understands Fortunato’s interment is a bad action.” (Sweet Jr., Online) Montresor ends by claiming “In speed requiescat” (Poe, Online). “Montresor’s prayer recommends that he needs remedy for regret, not forgiveness for a criminal activity” (Sweet Jr. 11). The sensation of salvation Montresor seeks through his confession does not take place. “For a confession to obtain absolution, the confessor needs to show the conviction of remorse. (Sugary Food Jr., Online) Montresor is incapable to achieve the salvation he seeks with the repression of Fortunato. The Amontillado represents Christ’s blood in communion. Christ’s blood provides the redemption that Montresor looks for. The Amontillado might lead Fortunato to his burial yet it symbolizes the redemption Montresor wishes to obtain via repression. Fortunato intends to consume alcohol the white wine out of satisfaction and also desire while Montresor sees the wine as something that brings him the bond of communion as well as the benefit of salvation.
Edgar Allan Poe’s uses paradoxical icons throughout “The Barrel of Amontillado.” The paradoxical symbols assisted him create the motif of looking for redemption with suppression. Fortunato’s character was able to represent male’s flesh and also exactly how individuals conveniently succumb to the sins of the flesh while Montresor stands for how male looks for redemption through acts of repression. Fortunato stands for the side of Montresor that ought to confess however Montresor selects to hide Fortunato which results in the failure of his own redemption.