The Scarlet Letter vs. the Great Gatsby
Are The Scarlet Letter and The Fantastic Gatsby Similar? The novel The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne is a novel based upon adultery and also pretension of culture. In recap, the unique discusses the story of Hester Prynne, a female that is going through a long as well as rough period in her life because she is dealing with significant conflicts with her culture due to the infidelity she has dedicated. Throughout the plot, Hester handle conflicts with herself as well as her culture when she is attempting to maintain the trick of who her other half is as well as that she had committed adultery with.
She is additionally in dispute with her spouse since he is not giving up on finding out that had an event with her. This classic unique shares numerous literary aspects with The Fantastic Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald. Nonetheless, can we claim that both books are similar? We will certainly discuss this issue by comparing and contrasting the major man tragic heroes in each story along with the very same motifs utilized in each books. Nathaniel Hawthorne, the author of The Scarlet Letter, was born on July fourth 1804, in Salem, Massachusetts. He was the 2nd kid of a U. S Navy Captain that died of yellow fever in Suriname in 1808.
Considering that he was only 4 years old, Nathaniel was increased by his older sibling and his mother. As he got older, he expanded this outrageous love for creating. He composed as well as released his first piece of literature, The Spectator, in the August of year 1820. To share his talents, he dispersed that newsmagazine to every one of his liked ones. A year later, Hawthorne goes into in Bowdoin College, where he ended up being buddies with the future poet, Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, and also future American Head of state, Franklin Pierce. He then graduated in four years later on in 1825. For the following 10 years, Hawthorne begins to isolate himself from the world.
He decides to quit speaking to family and friends to concentrate on his writing to achieve his goal on becoming an effective author. Three years after his years of extreme seclusion, Hawthorne publishes his first unique anonymously, Fanshawe. Regrettably, Fanshawe did not bring success to Hawthorne at all. After releasing two more short stories with his initial name, Nathaniel Hathorne, Hawthorne decides to include a “w” in his surname in 1830 for expert as well as individual uses. Nine years later on, Hawthorne locates a job at the Custom-made House in Boston.
A pair years after, he makes a decision to quit his task to relocate Brook Ranch in Massachusetts until the adhering to November. After a three-year engagement, Hawthorne marries a painter named Sophia Peabody on July 9th 1842. He after that has 2 youngsters with her: Una, his daughter, and also Julian, his child. A pair years after his kids’s birth, Hawthorne loses his task at the Salem Custom-made Home as a result of a political overhaul. To revenge his disappointment versus his community, he starts to work on The Scarlet Letter, a story that talks about pretension and adultery in Salem.
A month later, Hawthorne enters into a deep anxiety after the fatality of his mommy however still keeps writing on his novel which is released in March, 1850 and becomes a substantial success. A little over a decade later, after his third youngster was birthed, Hawthorne dies on Might 19th, 1864 on a getaway with Franklin Pierce, a close friend and the previous President of America. To begin, The Scarlet Letter as well as The Terrific Gatsby share many comparable attributes in both primary male personalities: Reverend Arthur Dimmesdale from The Scarlet Letter and Jay Gatsby from The Terrific Gatsby.
First of all, they had both dedicated adultery with the female they loved. Also, they are both tragic heroes; they are noble however imperfect, successful as well as powerful males yet handle irritation in their individual lives and, theses 2 characters brought their very own failure with their hamartia. Dimmesdale was a recognized Reverend that was talented with knowledge. He lived a lot of his life in privacy as well as regret when he maintained silent that he was the man who had dedicated infidelity with Hester Prynne.
Due to this, until he talked the truth, Hester was not respected as well as was discriminated in their neighborhood. Furthermore, their culture did not consider her child as a human due to the fact that they did not recognize that the daddy was. Gatsby was likewise an honorable and successful man yet he was not delighted with his life. He was dissatisfied of his past because his born right into a poor household and also he was trying to win back the love of his life however could not since she was wed. Gatsby and also Dimmesdale are likewise comparable in the truth that they were both experiencing for the female they enjoyed.
Dimmesdale actually wanted to disclose that he was the dad of Hester’s daughter yet did not wish to suffer from the effects. Gatsby likewise intended to expose his love for Daisy and win her back yet he needed to go beyond the obstacle of her being married to a different man. Although these 2 awful heroes are comparable, they likewise share some contracting components. To start with, they both stay in various amount of time; Dimmesdale stayed in the 19th century and also Gatsby lived in the 20th century. Furthermore, both characters have various definitions for love. For example, n the unique The Fantastic Gatsby, when Jay Gatsby admits his love for Sissy, we discover he is just concentrating on how much he liked her residence and her properties. “He had not as soon as stopped checking out Daisy, and I believe he revalued every little thing in his house according to the procedure of reaction it attracted from her well-liked eyes. Often, as well, he looked about at his belongings in a dazed means, as though in her actual as well as remarkable visibility none of it was any longer real. As soon as he almost toppled down a trip of staircases.” (Fitzgerald 96). Consequently, Gatsby just enjoyed Daisy for her wide range and her social class.
On the other hand, Arthur Dimmesdale truly enjoyed Hester Prynne for who she was from the beginning. Consequently, Gatsby is shallow compared to Dimmesdale. In addition, Gatsby did not have any actual good friends. The majority of individuals he hung out with where his company companions that only used him to generate income as well as attend his elegant parties. On the contrary, Dimmesdale was surrounded with people that truly loved him and respected him for who he was. This is why when Gatsby passed away, virtually nobody attended his funeral and also Dimmesdale passed away in the arms of his liked ones.
As a last point, these characters have both similar and contrasting elements. Additionally, The Scarlet Letter as well as The Excellent Gatsby both have common motifs: adultery and also the judgment of culture. Using contrast, the exact same styles of each tale are described in a different way. To start, in both stories, the style of adultery is explained together: adultery will bring about numerous consequences. It is the motif of exactly how culture is evaluating adultery that is important. In the unique, The Scarlet Letter, Hester Prynne had an affair with Dimmesdale and her culture did not agree with this action.
She was punished for her decisions and also had to spend years being differentiated by her very own friends and next-door neighbors. It wasn’t up until completion of guide, when Dimmesdale stepped forward of him being Pearl’s daddy, that Hester and Dimmesdale looked for mercy and ended up being without guilt by becoming better people. As Pearl grew older, Hester’s society appreciated her and respected her as a mommy figure;” Such helpfulness was located in her– so much power to do and power to sympathize– that lots of people refused to translate the scarlet “A” by its initial signification.
They stated it was “Able”; so solid was Hester Prynne, with a lady’s stamina” (Hawthorne 145). Therefore, in the time period that Hester stayed in, her community placed a great deal of energy as well as cares in the direction of custom and also did not count on those satanic actions. Nonetheless, in the novel, The Fantastic Gatsby, when Tom had his affairs with Myrtle and also when Sissy had her events with Gatsby, all of their family and friends knew about it but did not care because it was none of their company. The culture they stayed in only cared about living the American dream.
These personalities just dedicated adultery for the enjoyment of it. They had no regret for one another. Yet, Sissy and also Tom both felt guilty when the people they were committing infidelity with had died of awful mishaps. They were both dealing with their pains. It was only Nick Carraway, Daisy’s relative, who thought that their actions were unacceptable as well as disgusting. As a final point, both novels share similar motifs yet are evaluated differently. To answer the concern, Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter, resembles F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Fantastic Gatsby.
We can conclude with this answer due to the fact that Arthur Dimmesdale as well as Jay Gatsby are 2 various characters that made the same mistakes and also had the very same passions: dedicating infidelity with the woman they enjoyed and also wanting to be with them for the remainder of their lives no matter just how large their barriers are. Likewise, both novels share the exact same themes as well as messages on exactly how adultery can create an adverse affect in one’s life. On the various other hand, given that both stories were created in various amount of time, the neighborhood in where the personalities stayed in had a different point of view on adultery. Functions cited Fitzgerald, F.
Scott, as well as Matthew J. Bruccoli. The Great Gatsby. New York City: Collier, 1992. Publish. “Nathaniel Hawthorne– Biography.” Nathaniel Hawthorne. N. p., n. d. Web. 13 Jan. 2013. “Nathaniel Hawthorne Timeline.” Shmoop. N. p., n. d. Internet. 13 Jan. 2013. Hawthorne, Nathaniel. The Scarlet Letter: Consists Of DVD. New York City: Signet Classics, 2005. Print.—————————— ”Nathaniel Hawthorne Timeline.” Shmoop. N. p., n. d. Internet. 13 Jan. 2013.  “Nathaniel Hawthorne– Biography. “Nathaniel Hawthorne. N. p., n. d. Internet. 13 Jan. 2013.  Hamartia: imperfection, blunder or mistake.