Hit enter after type your search item

The Things They Carried : True vs. False


The Things They Brought: True vs. False

How do you choose what is true and what is incorrect? In war the line blurs a lot more. We hear war stories and question the truth of these stories. We enjoy to think the stories of heroism and bravery. Now how do we know that these stories are genuine and not developed propaganda? The Important Things They Brought by Tim O? Brien is a fiction book that shines some light on war stories. This complex book focuses on an intricate war. The Vietnam War was complicated for the factors surrounding it.

Some of the factors were; the concern why we were over there, governments that told half truths on what was going on, and the style of fighting was absolutely various compared to the previous wars. This new design is called guerrilla warfare. O? Brien composes stories that make you believe that they are real, however the book is fiction. In? How to Inform a True War Story? he provides his rules on informing a real war story, and perhaps assist us clean up some of the incorrect stories about the war. I will take a few of these guidelines and stories to show if they are real or not. Among O? Brien? stories is? Church. This is a true war story since it has absolutely nothing to do with the war, but deals with 2 guys? s thoughts on faith. Among the rules O? Brien stated is? A real war story is never about war? (83) shows that this is true. A real war story is about humiliation, memory, grief, and love. (O? Brien) It? s about the land and the bulge. An example remains in WWII when the U. S. A. dropped the atomic bomb. It? s not about the dropping of the atomic bomb, however about the thoughts and has a hard time in the minds of the team who dropped the atomic bomb, or it? about the kid forty years later on who still is affected from the nuclear blast. Now? Church? has to do with the soldiers who set up a main office for a week in a partially deserted pagoda. A pagoda is a temple used to worship a god. 2 monks live there who were peaceful males. Kiowa, one of the soldiers who brings the New Testimony with him, states? It? s bad news? You put on? t tinker churches? (O? Brien 119). Kiowa believed you wear? t established base inside a church. Kiowa and Henry Dobbins discuss faith during their time there. This story is not about war although it? s in war, and they use the church as a base.

Kiowa and Dobbins talk of their church experiences, and Dobbins talk about his idea of becoming a minister. This story is about the faith each believes in. Dobbins just wanted to be great to individuals, however war change him. Kiowa on the other hand brings his Bible around, however his faith is more like a blanket or sanctuary. It is just what he matured with. A huge part of this story is the contradiction that they are in a church, however they remain in a war using the church as a base. War is not about morals. Like Dobbins says after the monks left after they completed clean his gatling gun?

You? re right? All you can do is be good. Treat them good, you know (O? Brien 123). So you can see that war isn? t about war; it is about everyone? s morals and beliefs. In war you expect death from shooting or opponent weapons, however in the story? In the Field? the enemy was the land.? In the Field? is the story where Lieutenant Jimmy Cross and the males face a death from the unknown. Jimmy Cross ordered the men to set up camp beside the Tune Tra Bong River. Even though he knew this was going to be an issue. It was drizzling which triggered the river to over circulation.

2 residents had warned him that it was a bad spot, and part of him knew that he must of gone to higher grounds, however he was following orders. During the night mortar rounds went off hitting near Kiowa who was sucked down into the marshy ground. The mortar round was shot because a young kid, name unknown, switched on a flashlight to reveal an image of his sweetheart to Kiowa. Kiowa died that night. He passed away in a field called a shit field. As Azar stated, Wasted in the waste? A shit field. You got to admit, it? s pure world-class irony. (O? Brien 165). This is a true war story,? It never ever appears to ends? O? Brien 76) and Makes the stomach think? (O? Brien 78). It is a story that you feel once again and again. You feel various emotions from Kiowa death (sadness), to the blame many felt for Kiowa? s death (guilt), to the vulnerability as good friends search for Kiowa (stress and anxiety), to their response when they lastly discover Kiowa. Jimmy Cross was very weighed down for the death that he understood he could have changed. He feels the need to write Kiowa? s daddy and inform him that he is to blame. The young boy felt a responsibility for the death of his new good friend. He knew his flashlight made the mortar rounds come.

He hears the screams of Kiowa. In the morning he might not tell Jimmy Cross the real story of what happened. All he did was try to find his girlfriend? s picture, for he knew Kiowa was dead. The young boy kept searching for his picture. After Jimmy Cross stated he could get another one, however the boy understood he couldn? t due to the fact that it was not his girlfriend anymore and she wouldn? t send him another one. Your stomach turns as you see Kiowa being explained when they pull him out. His shoulder is missing, arms and cheek are cut up with shrapnel, and he is covered in bluish green goop.

Norman Bowker informs everyone that there is no one to blame. Jimmy Cross thinks this in his mind, You might blame the war. You might blame the morons who made the war. You could blame Kiowa for going to it. You might blame the rain. You could blame the river. You might blame the field, the mud, the climate. You could blame the enemy. You could blame the mortar rounds? You could blame God. (O? Brien 177). The story never ever ends because it triggers Tim O? Brien to come back to the spot with his child. The story never ever ends due to the fact that it is the crazy stuff that keeps it alive in them.

Throughout war, soldiers are changed by the war.? You can tell a true war story by its outright and uncompromising allegiance to profanity and evil? (O? Brien 69). This is among O? Brien rules for telling a war story. The violence seen by the soldiers, and the morality vanishes once they get in war. This impacts the lives of the soldiers a lot so that they realize at the end that they have actually altered. This modification is normally toward the evil acts of humans. It makes good sense that wicked and profanity affect the soldiers since they remain in a place where there are no guidelines and no morals.

Soldiers are in a way reduced to an animal instinct were you or your enemy remains. In Iraq some of the jail guards have actually done extremely harmful acts against the detainees. The environment altered these guards by bringing them to do these acts. An extra reality is not all of these guards were guys some of them were women. This is not expected from our guards by military standards or public morals especially from females.? The Ghost Soldiers? exposes this type of wicked or obscenity in the life of Tim O? Brien himself. This story starts with informing the stories of the 2 times O?

Brien got shot. When he tells the stories he compares the different treatment he obtained from two different medics. The first shot was to the side, but Rat, the medic, right away put a compress on it. Despite the fact that there was an intense battle going on, Rat went to him 4 times to alter his compress and to look at him. O? Brien returned twenty-six days later, but Rat was gone, and a new medic fresh from home took over Rat? s position. His name was Bobby Jorgenson. O? Brien? s 2nd shot was to the butts, but unlike Rat, Bobby was slow and frightened by the occasion.

This poor treatment triggered a few things. O? Brien was eliminated of active service due to the fact that of the poor treatment of his gun wound. It caused him some humiliation because the nurses and other soldiers teased him. This caused O? Brien? s hatred for Bobby. When the Alpha Business pertained to the base O? Brien was at, they partied and told stories. But all O? Brien might think of was Bobby. He consistently asked people where he was, but they told him to drop it. His hatred grew while they were there. He ultimately prepared what was to be a joke on Bobby, to terrify him.

He teamed up with Azar who is probably the most immoral person in the Alpha Company. While they were playing the joke, O? Brien breaks down since he knew what he was doing was immoral and childish. The important things is O? Brien was so deep in his hatred and his own evil that his true self was hidden deep inside himself. The revenge was consuming at him.? There was that coldness inside me. I wasn? t myself. I felt hollow and harmful? (O? Brien 207). He understood his actions were cruel, but he was aliened with vengeance, evil and profanity. This is what made the story genuine. O? Brien? s stories are simple to think.

The method he explains occasions. You feel like you are there. He is an excellent writer thinking about that the majority of this is factually fake. He composes to show individuals the opposite of war that we may not have seen. His experience from remaining in Vietnam actually shows people the opposite of Vietnam. In war we look for heroism and bravery to be the designs of soldiers, but it seems that war is not that. It is more survival of your own emotions as you see and experience war and death. I have not been to war so I wear? t totally know. Work Citied O? Brien, Tim. The Things They Brought. New York City: Broadway Books, 1990.

This div height required for enabling the sticky sidebar