At their deepest degree, both The Policy of St. Benedict and also Beowulf handle the question of exactly how one can tackle utilizing his short time in the world to attain a kind of eternity in the face of a harmful, threatening, unforeseeable globe. The Regulation of St. Benedict, for instance, is a collection of Christian policies introducing the “devices of the spiritual craft” that are meant to be “utilized without ceasing, night and day” (St. Benedict, 14) so that on the Day of Judgment, “our salaries will certainly be the benefit the Lord has actually assured” (St. Benedict, 14). Alternatively, Beowulf is an Anglo-Saxon legendary that glorifies the brave duties of warriors and warrior-kings in a manner that only track record will certainly bolster a warrior’s existence after fatality. Therefore, while St. Benedict proposed that the method to an eternal life is by leading a righteous as well as Godly life, Beowulf suggests that the way to an immortality is with the Germanic heroic code; in addition, both messages reveal resemblances and distinctions in the worth systems of these cultures.
In The Regulation of St. Benedict, eternity is a location where those who have actually lived in divine obedience will certainly get to experience (St. Benedict, 14), and those who have not will spend their immortalities in the “torments of heck” (St. Benedict, 5). The way to an immortality is by living a God-fearing life in the here-and-now; by giving up his very own will, doing “the will of him that sent me” (St. Benedict, 15), “humbling our hearts” (St. Benedict, 16), and yearning “for long lasting life with divine desire” (St. Benedict, 13). While St. Benedict’s abbots as well as monks invested every passing minute preparing– doing “good works” (St. Benedict, 12)– for delight in the afterlife, Beowulf’s warrior-kings and warriors keep that honor is gained throughout life via good heroic deeds. In Beowulf, endless time is memory and family tree, achieved by obeying the principles of the Germanic heroic code: Beowulf states, “As we must all anticipate to leave our life on earth, we should make some renown, if we can, before death; daring is things for a fighting man to be remembered by” (Beowulf, lines 1385-1388). Beowulf’s determination to recognize his daddy’s relationship with King Hrothgar by clearing his kingdom of Grendel’s tyranny exemplifies this; a capable warrior has to utilize his capabilities to combat evil right of all, as a warrior is “given delight in fight” (Beowulf, line 63). It is indicated that, for Beowulf‘s warriors and warrior-kings, “hell” is either not being kept in mind as a hero or not having worthy forefathers.
In addition, there are battles along the method to achieving immortality. In Beowulf, Grendel, Grendel’s mommy, and the venomous dragon best represent these battles. Hrothgar fails as a warrior-king to shield his kingdom from Grendel and sees that each of his warriors “after that maintained himself at a much safer distance” (Beowulf, line 142) until Grendel as well as his mother are killed, however Beowulf successfully shields his own kingdom as a warrior-king by dealing with the poisonous dragon at the end of the story. In The Guideline of the St. Benedict, on the other hand, these battles are stood for by transgressions, such as overindulgence, product possessiveness, and also “unrefinement as well as chatter as well as talk” that cause laughter (St. Benedict, 18). If an abbot stops working in his responsibility to teach God’s rules as well as a monk strays from the Godly life, St. Benedict believed it is the abbot that “will birth the blame” (St. Benedict, 8) as well as both the abbot and the guilty monk threaten their possibilities at immortality. Thus, one loses his shot at infinity by providing into life’s struggles, because attaining infinity calls for a battle; “everyday with tears and sighs” (St. Benedict, 13) for St. Benedict’s abbots and monks, delight in battle for Beowulf’s warrior-kings as well as warriors.
Although the methods which the subjects in these texts accomplish eternal life are various, the underlying messages in both of these texts expose incredibly comparable value systems. As St. Benedict stated to “enjoy your next-door neighbor as yourself” (St. Benedict, 12), Beowulf adheres to this concept when he goes to Denmark to totally free Hrothgar as well as his kingdom from the tyranny of Grendel. Along with this, St. Benedict claimed, “overindulgence is stayed clear of” (St. Benedict, 41). If Grendel symbolizes gluttony by his excessive victimizing Hrothgar’s men, after that it is sensible in conclusion that Beowulf‘s society additionally abided by this concept. One more value that these two messages deal with is vengeance: “Do not repay one bad turn with one more” (St. Benedict, 12). Because Grendel’s mother pertains to Heorot to retaliate Grendel’s death, and also Beowulf inevitably defeats her, it seems that Beowulf additionally shares the worth that vengeance is a fatal flaw. The treasure-hoarding dragon in Beowulf shows up to stand for St. Benedict’s rule that “all things need to be the common ownership of all” (St. Benedict, 36) and that “circulation” is “made to each one has he” has “require” (St. Benedict, 37), i.e. the dragon has no demand for the prize he is hoarding and also when he is killed the prize is distributed to the people of the kingdom. Last But Not Least, St. Benedict’s idea that the abbot is the “shepherd” that births “the blame wherever the papa of the household locates that the lamb have actually yielded to make money” (St. Benedict, 8) is sustained in Beowulf by the concept that Hrothgar’s warriors were faithful and loyal to him until he fell short as a warrior-king to safeguard them from Grendel.
In contrast, the reality that eternity is gained by battle success in Beowulf and spiritual piety in The Regulation of St. Benedict recommends that there are also a couple of differences in their value systems. As an example, while Grendel’s mommy’s death can stand for vengeance as a fatal flaw, as suggested above, it is likewise really apparent that this culture went after the instruction of justice by vengeance: Beowulf claims to Hrothgar, “It is much better for a guy to retaliate his friend than to revitalize his sorrow” (Beowulf, lines 1383-1384). Because the Christian teaching supports a calm, flexible attitude towards one’s opponents (St. Benedict, 12), it is possible that these clashing interpretations might be discussed by the reality that this pre-Christian story is informed by a Christian author. Another incongruity between the values of St. Benedict’s world and also Beowulf‘s world is that of satisfaction. Beowulf‘s warriors and warrior-kings pride themselves on their victories openly, while St. Benedict urges his fans to associate their achievements to God (St. Benedict, 13) and to humble themselves (St. Benedict, 16). Ultimately, St. Benedict’s and Beowulf‘s cultures both valued stamina as well as bravery, although their interpretations of these features vary. For St. Benedict, toughness and fearlessness are “spiritual tools” (St. Benedict, 14) that aid Christians stay devoted to God and also avoid giving right into earthly temptations; for Beowulf’s society, stamina and also valor are actually vital to an effective battle.
In both The Regulation of St. Benedict and Beowulf, life has lots of challenges that individuals have to beautifully get over in order to accomplish eternal life. Beowulf dealt with many fights, some harder than others; St. Benedict’s abbots and also monks had to avoid the fleshly lures of life (St. Benedict, 13). St. Benedict’s abbots and monks led exemplary and Godly lives, while Germanic warrior-kings and also warriors recognized victorious splendor and also commitment to kinship. Lastly, infinity in Beowulf is memory, while endless time for St. Benedict is Heaven.
Works Pointed out
Beowulf: a verse translation. Modified edition, tr. Michael Alexander. London: Penguin Books, 2001. isbn=0140449310
St. Benedict. The Rule of St. Benedict in English. Ed. Timothy Fry. Collegeview, Minnesota: Vintage Spiritual Classics, 1998. isbn=037570017